Join the Congregation!|Saturday, June 23, 2018
You are here: Home » 2013 » Padres Turned Down Tigers Offer for Porcello

Padres Turned Down Tigers Offer for Porcello 

Rick Porcello - Photo by Keith Allison

Rick Porcello – Photo by Keith Allison

Jim Bowden has reported via twitter

According to Tigers source the Padres have turned down Porcello for Street and Porcello for Gregorson but talks continue

The Padres were first rumored to have interest in Rick Porcello back in December.  Talks were on, then off, then on, and now this.  The encouraging part of this tweet is “talks continue”, the discouraging part is that it seems Josh Byrnes has decided protecting his investments are more important than good judgment.

On my radio show last Saturday I touched on how all general managers, not just Byrnes have the best interest in mind of players they bring in (#Byrnesboys).  This way when the team wins, the general managers finger prints all over it.    When asked at a season ticket holder meeting, how the Padres would spent the TV money, the response (and I’m paraphrasing) was, we re-signed Quentin and Street.

Committing $27MM to oft-injured Carlos Quentin for three years and $14MM to Huston Street wasn’t exactly how fans envision the Padres using the extra TV money.  I’m not going to question that Quentin and Street can produce when healthy, but I will question giving over $40 million to guys that are going to be injured 1/3 to ½ the season.  Also, keep in mind that Edinson Volquez is a free agent after 2013, and Clayton Richard after 2014.

So Josh Bynres has decided to keep an injury-prone, short-term closer when starting pitching was and still is your biggest need this off-season, while declining a trade for a 24 year-old controllable arm when you know the guys you have (back-end starters on most teams) are leaving?   Okay, just making sure we are all on the same page.

I’m not concerned about Porcello’s contract given the fact, the Padres have stated that they have money to spend and his contract would be off-set from moving Street this year and losing Volquez next.  Porcello is also just 24 and is under team control through 2015.  Let’s just hope that the Padres front office returns from this off-season siesta in time to return the Tigers call.



About the author: Steve Adler

Steve is the founder of A native San Diegan, he grew up watching Dan Fouts and Tony Gwynn. A former sports talk show host, but always a fan of the Padres and Chargers.

  • We don´t know exactly what the Tigers asked for, and the Tigers reportedly also turned down several offers from Byrnes, so perhaps the asking price just wasn´t to his liking. With this information available, one at least has to give him the benefit of the doubt.

  • itsfun

    Tigers deny the rumor of offering Porcello for a relief pitcher. Porcello is worth a lot more than a relief pitcher that has made 6 trips to the DL. Porcello is a 24 year old pitcher with 48 big league wins. He is a ground ball pitcher and the Tigers are not known for infield defense. Porcello has the chance to become a outstanding big league pitcher and I would not trade him for anything less than an all star shortstop and a very good pitching prospect. The shortstop would also need to be signed for at least 4 years before the trade. All I hear from the “experts” is pitching wins. If that is true, a all star type shortstop and a very good prospect is not to big a asking price.